top of page
0569264
Muro_PRT_Fore
Sun_Front
tcs0106
Woodwall Starb
dehnert02
IMG_7143
USS Allen M Sumner, 1967
IndLam8
USS Allen M Sumner, 1971
Starb detail
Starb_MIdships_detil
IndLam6
IMG_7049
For scale 2
Starb_Fore_Detail 2
_IndLam3
IMG_7057
IndLam2
IMG_7051
Sun_Port_up
Whitewall_Portaft
IMG_7052
Wall_Port1JPG
Muro_Port_Aft
IMG_7060
IndLam5
IMG_7054
IndLam4
IMG_7059
IndLam1
Muro_PRT_1
Muro_STB_3
Port up 1

Click on a picture in the gallery above to see a full resolution image, or to navigate manually

USS Allen M Sumner (DD 692), FRAM II
Mediterranean Sea, August 1970

Why this ship?

​

The Sumner class destroyers (including the lead, USS Allen M Sumner, in particular) had a distinguished career that spanned many tough years including World War 2, Korea, and Vietnam. Part of their longevity comes from being fundamentally good designs, built upon the success of the Fletcher class. But part also comes from becoming major subjects of the FRAM (Fleet Rehabilitation and Modernisation) program, developed and promoted by Adm. Arleigh Burke in response to the rapid expansion of the Soviet submarine Fleet in the 50s. FRAM II saw a large number of Sumners undertaking major surgery during the 1960's, which included gaining a helipad and modernisation of armament and sensors.

 

Once they became surplus to the US Navy many were transferred to various allies, including Brazil, where they became familiar "faces" during my early years. On a memorable instance I was on board of the tug that was pulling the target for gunnery practice by Sumner- and Gearing-class ships.

​​

What was added

Quite a lot, actually...

  • The kit came with 2 excellent photoetch frets, so most of the metal was out-of-the-box. The exception were the whip antennas, which were represented using tungsten rods. The more complex broadband antenna on top of mount 2 also used memory metal rigging line from Galaxy.

  • Many details were simply not represented in the kit, so quite a few were scratch-built. The list includes (but is not restricted to) the AS-1018 and AT-948 antennas on top of the mast, the AS-1018 on top of mount 1, various lights and tannoys, the Mk25 torpedo launchers, and an assortment of lockers. I used the FRAM conversion shipyard plans to fill some of the gaps.

  • Whereas the photoetch frets include the racks for the life rafts, the rolled rafts themselves are absent. I represented these using Mk6 inflatable life rafts from HS models (not exactly the correct model, but close enough in 1/700).

  • The four 12" searchlights near the Mk25 director and signalman's shelter were from a WULA model set (1/700 US Navy searchlights WLD7000057).

  • The Mk32 torpedo tubes that came in the kit were too short and tick, so I substituted with 3D printed, correctly shaped ones (from Camel Model).

  • The Hedgehog projectors that came in the kit were out of scale, being way too large by about 50%. Again, the solution was aftermarket, and the ones you see are from Black Cat model (AC700013).

  • The watertight doors and hatches came folded into the resin, but they were just too soft and fuzzy. I added those on top of the resin, drawing from the Fivestar set (WWII USN Watertight Door & Hatch, FS700010).

  • The chocks that came as part of the resin hull would not allow me to fit railings. They were just too close to the edge of the deck. The solution was to chop them off and add photoetch chocks (Bigblueboy USN Modern Railing I, 70033).

  • Torpedo handling machinery in the midships deck was sourced from the 1/700 Niko model kit of the same ship (see below), which fortunately comes with a spare.

  • The white weather cloths usually seen covering the top level railings were done by stretching a film of Micro Krystal Klear along the rails, letting it dry, then painting with Tamiya white enamel (XF-2).

  • Rigging used a mixture of Uschi and AK elastic threads.

  • A sea base was created using my usual technique.

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​​​

Hover the mouse over the image on top of the gallery for figure legends

​What you get the you buy this kit: ​Image 1: The kit comes in a non-labeled styrofoam box. These are the box contents. Images 2 and 3: The resin parts are pretty rough. They have a grainy surface, and some flash. They require a lot of sanding and multiple coats of surfacer. Image 4: The smaller bits of resin are also rough. Note that conjoined whaler and VDS spool (red arrow) and the way-too-big hedgehogs (blue arrows) Image 5: The photoetch on the other hand is superb. This is one of the two frets. Plenty of spares, too. Images 6-7: 3D printed parts include the 5"/38 cal gun mounts, and the barrels. Plenty of spare blast bags too. Image 8: The decals are OK. Image 9: the kit also comes with some metal for the masts and thread for rigging, which I preferred not to use.

​

Lessons learned and problems circumvented​

Before starting on a litany of complaints, let me begin by pointing out that I ran out of patience waiting for a modern injection moulded kit of a post-FRAM Sumner. It seems incredible that no major company has decided to make FRAM-cans available, considering how many of us still have fond memories of them. This has left the field to be occupied by smaller players.

 

This particular kit is sold on eBay as an "unbranded" 3D printed kit. In reality, it is a mixed-medium kit (resin hull + photoetch + a few 3D printed parts). The kit gives you the basics, but you need to invest a lot in terms of scratch-building to build and correct. Since I started this build, another 1/700 Sumner option became available, from Niko Model. I also have this one, which I intend to build for comparison, but this is a story for another day.

​

​The negatives:

  • The main issue is that this kit comes with no instructions. So, if you want a nice relaxed build, this is not for you. You have to figure out what the parts are by looking hard at photos of the ship and the aforementioned shipyard plans, and comparing those with the resin and photoetch. I have done my best to create a rough step by step guide (see here) but in the end there is still a lot left for interpretation.

  • The resin parts are poor, ranking easily as the worst I have tried to use. They have a rough surface, which took forever to get to some acceptable state using a combination of sanding and surfacer (Mr Surfacer 500, followed by 1000, followed by SMS surfacer grey). There is also a lot of flash to cut off, and gaps to fill. Finally, there are some inexplicable inaccuracies. For example, the midship section containing the torpedo deck is not centred on the hull, being instead somehow shifted to starboard. This creates a problem when you try to fit the boat racks and davits, because there is not enough room. I did the best I could...

 

The positives:

  • The photoetch sheets are excellent. The metal is easily cut, bends along well marked lines, and is measured precisely to go...once you figure out where exactly they should go.

  • The decals also performed well. They were printed in register, and played well with Microset and Microsol. The only issue is that the ship's crests on the side of the superstructure were not provided. In the end, this was something else that I had to borrow from the Niko Model kit (which, again fortunately, comes with two sets, each appropriate for a different period of time).

  • The 3D printed armament is a nice touch, but requires some surgery to allow the guns to fit in the mounts.

​

​

​

​

​

​​

​

​

​​​​

 

Fixing the 3D printed armament: Left: As provided, the blast bags are too large, making the guns sit in an unnatural position. Centre: The bottom of the guns need to be trimmed (bottom piece is the original, next to two trimmed ones). Right: following the trimming, the blast bags and barrels sit appropriately.

​​

More photos...

​

​​

​

​

​​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​​​​​

Click on a picture in the gallery above to see a full resolution image, or to navigate manually​

​

Painting​

  • The first step was to soak everything in kitchen detergent overnight, followed by air-drying and spraying with isopropyl alcohol (to remove any residue from the resin casting).

  • Then airbrushing was used to build up layers of surfacer, to get rid of the grainy appearance of the resin hull. I started with several Mr. Surfacer coats, but reserved the final touch for SMS Grey surfacer (PLP01).

  • The horizontal surfaces were then airbrushed with SMS V-Line grey (PL109; which best matches my memory of their colour), except for the flight deck (SMS dark sea grey, PL56). A lot of masking then had to be done, before the vertical surfaces were painted with SMS Haze Grey (PL119). 

​

​​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

A lot of fiddly masking! Left: After masking the flight deck with tape, the next step was to carefully follow the perimeter of the superstructure. Right: The rest was done with Abteilung 502 Liquid Mask (ABT115), which I find gives me a lot of control in the process.

​​​

  • Small corrections to the vertical surfaces were done with Tamiya enamel light sea grey (XF-25), largely dry-brushed to avoid sharp transitions. For the horizontals, I used Vallejo extra dark sea grey and AK dark grey (also dry-brushed). I also used  Mission Models MMP-104 (Haze Grey US Navy 5H) to dry-brush some spots, adding just a bit of variation to avoid the impression of an unnaturally "tidy" ship.

  • Once happy with the overall effect, everything was covered in SMS clear gloss (PL09), and the decals were applied. As mentioned above, the majority of the decals were originals from the kit, but the ship's crest was from the Niko Model kit.

  • Weathering was done with very diluted Tamiya enamels (e.g. XF-9 hull red for rust streaks in the hull, X-19 smoke to create dirt patches in the greys). Some dry-brushing of Tamiya weathering master powders (primarily, "soot" and "oil stain") was also done, notably to create dirty patches on the decks. My reference image for the rust streaks came from the DD-692 veterans web site (reproduced below):

​

​

​

​

​

​​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​​​​

  • The last step, after the masts were placed and rigging was applied, was to seal everything with SMS Premium flat clear (PL10).

 

 

 

 

 

 

​​​​​​​​​​​​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

 

Click on a picture in the gallery above to see a full resolution image, or to navigate manually

​

In summary: 

There aren't many options out there if you want to build FRAM-cans in their classical, Vietnam-era configurations. Buying this un-branded kit, for which I could find no reviews, took a leap of faith.  

​

The main take-home message is that this kit is a combination of outstanding photoetch parts with poor resin parts. Given the latter, it will never look as good as a kit coming from an established manufacturer. The main obstacle will always be the lack of instructions. But, with patience and a lot of looking at reference photos, something that resembles a Sumner can be built. To save you some trouble should you try to build the same model, I have created a "work in progress" thread here, which hopefully will save some time in identifying the parts. 

​​

In summary, I cannot recommend this kit. Even if you are a FRAM aficionado who can't wait, I would try the Niko Model offering first, a brand with which I have had a better experience. I put this build in the same category as my build of HMS Vanguard, as a hit I took for the team so that the Gods of modelling would give us a modern injection moulded kit. Let's see if this works.

​​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​​​​

Click on a picture in the gallery above to see a full resolution image, or to navigate manually

​

​

​

​​​​

3D printed gun barrels sit too high on turret
3D printed gun barrels trimmed to fit
5" gun turret after gun barrels modified
Early step in masking the deck
Masking the deck, using liquid mask
An example of hull streaks in the USS Allen M Sumner
1/700 Gallery

Construction photos

Click on a picture in the gallery above to see a full resolution image, or to navigate manually

bottom of page